Churchianity isn’t Christianity

Academy awards are given to recognize excellence in the motion picture industry. The best in broadway theatre and stage arts are given the prized ‘Tony Award.’ When I think of great actors, I have to gloss over the Hollywood elite of today who are aided by special effects and technological advances. Names synonymous with great acting are the classics like Bogart, Cagney, Robinson, Gable, Bergman, and Hepburn. These iconic actors and actresses are famous for their ability to make us forget they are simply playing the part of some character. When we watch them, they become the good guy or the gangster. It took me less than a minute to dislike Scarlet O’Hara because Vivien Leigh portrayed her spoiled entitled character so well. I found myself rooting for ‘soldier’ played by Bogart because Edward G. Robinson did such a great job becoming the notorious gangster ‘Johnny Rocco’ and it was easy to forget he was just acting.

What do the great actors of film have to do with last days Christianity? Quite a lot because we live in a day when it’s not easy to differentiate between the true followers of Jesus and those who are simply Christian actors. I don’t know what motivates one to be a pretender instead of the real thing. One thing is certain: Churchianity isn’t Christianity.

Before I continue please let me tell you that I’m not down on the church. In fact, I love the fellowship I attend because there are so many who love the Lord there, that is the church. Our body of believers, individual and corporately plus believers worldwide make up the church that makes anyone who belongs to Jesus, part of the same family. When I use the term: Churchianity, I have a very distinct way of life in mind, much different than biblical Christianity.  It is a word synonymous with pseudo-Christianity, someone who loudly wears the Christian label, but is simply a convincing actor.

I have two primary reasons for writing this article. The first is to put out a loving warning to you. I want to remind you that there are some who attend our church, small group, Bible study, and everyday functions who are not the real deal. This matters because these are the times when teaching, belief, and conversation may be introduced that either inadvertently or by design, takes our focus off the word of God and puts the focus on what we think.  1 Timothy 4:1    

As true believers, it is vital that we set the direction of the conversation and direct it squarely on the Bible. It may be necessary to correct or reprove someone who seeks to focus off the Bible and on the prevailing thinking of the culture. When we do this, our motive should always be restoration.  2 Timothy 2:24  

The other reason for this article is this:   All of us (myself included) have to check our own heart motives. We never want to get caught up in the game of playing Christian for our own glory, reputation, and man pleasing. We must keep our motives pure, make our walk about God, and bring glory to Him, not ourselves. Thinking about heart motives, some people indeed have very wrong reasons for calling themselves Christian. Perhaps they desire the praise of man. They are busy bees in church and very active in every outreach program. That can be a very good thing and as believers, we should be people who are moved by love to serve. The problem always comes down to motive. If they are driven by the attention, affirmation, and applause of men they receive, then their motive for serving isn’t God’s glory but their own.

Is it possible to ‘play the part’ of Christian for its fringe benefits? I think the answer is a strong yes. It just might help us get the handsome guy or pretty lady who is a real believer. Being an actor may fool people into believing you are trustworthy when you know the real you. We may even become so self-deluded in our ‘acting’ that we may think we have God fooled. We might be so accustomed to hearing the cheers of man and patting ourselves on the back so much that we start believing we are the real deal. What a sad and eternally dangerous game to play.

Our heart’s motive must be making much of God and nothing of ourselves. Matthew 6:2 

Is it possible to be immersed and surrounded by ‘religious activity’ and not be saved? The answer unfortunately is yes. The rulers, elders, and leadership in Jesus’ day were certainly in this group. They are a prime example of being so immersed by form, function, and religious tradition…..that they were blind to the truth. They were confronted with the truth when John the Baptist came on the scene and then Jesus’ ministry could not go unnoticed…..unless you were blinded by ‘a form of godliness.’ If Jesus isn’t the very center of your life, then all of your religious activities make you an actor living in the realm of Churchianity, not Christianity. Matthew 6:5

This is a sad part to play because, at the end when every deed is before the eyes of the Lord for judgment, it would be tragic to hear, “Depart from me you worker of lawlessness, I never knew you.” On the surface, it may be difficult to tell who is a Christian from those actors in ‘Churchianity. But upon closer inspection, the differences are stark by comparison. The Bible makes it clear that we are known by our fruit. This fruit becomes evident in the routine of everyday life. The type of fruit we produce depends on what spirit is guiding us. If we submit to God’s will, then the Holy Spirit’s fruit is all over our life. On the other hand, if we are driven by reputation, praise, stature, and selfishness, then the spirit of this world drives us.

I have witnessed two extremes over the years: One extreme is the person who is into externals and wearing their faith out loud.

I’m not talking about being so fired up for the Lord that you take your Bible to school & work to read or being so full of God’s joy and presence that people know you are different by your actions, attitude, and kindness because that is simply outward evidence and fruit of a real relationship with the Lord.

The extreme I’m referring to is someone who plays the ‘part’ of Christian, but in reality, may not be truly converted. Oh yes, they are full of Christian platitudes, and church activities, and may even carry a Bible with them. But the reality is that these people are mere actors who for reasons I don’t understand. They want to be in and around Christianity but never become a true Christian.

The second extreme I’ve witnessed is the person who isn’t an actor. This person is the one whose life is marked by true godliness. They are people of true joy and peace. They come in all ages and personality types. Some are fired up for the Lord inside and out. They share the gospel with almost everybody they come in contact with. This enthusiasm is bolstered by fasting, prayer, and immersion into the word of God.  Some of these folks are quiet types but inside they are taking the war to the enemy in the prayer closet. The bottom line is that the people in this extreme are 100% authentic followers of Jesus. There are no actors here, only disciples. Are they perfect people? Absolutely not but they all have one thing as a defining characteristic. Every one of them realized the desperate condition of their heart before a holy God and they all cried out to His Son for salvation. The way they live now is simply an outflow of the spirit of God living inside and surrendering to His will daily. Far from being a stage production, it is evidence of true Christianity. Jude 20  

When it comes to people we come in contact with that are playing the part of Christians. The most loving thing we can do is admonish them with truth from God’s word in hope of restoration. It would be beautiful if they exchanged pseudo-Christianity for the real thing. On the other hand, if the person has a life pattern of being unyielding and undermining the gospel with strange or ‘new’ teaching that isn’t supported in the Bible, they may sway or confuse those who are new and young in the faith with this false teaching. In this case, a person is a tool of the enemy. They need a strong rebuke and disassociation for a time. Continue to pray for the Spirit’s conviction, they may come to the knowledge of the truth one day and fellowship may be restored.

These are days when hyper faith, prosperity gospel, and Christianese social clubs are doubling as authentic Christianity. This religious activity masquerading as Christianity is just that, religious activity. In these dark days, we need to be salt and light, not players on a religious stage. Let’s keep our lives focussed on living for the Lord and His glory as the end result.

All for Him,

Howard

About Howard Green
I'm Howard Green, an evangelist and writer at Concerning The Times. My work has appeared in The Christian Post, Olive Tree Views, Rapture Ready, Levitt Letter, The Berean Call, and other Christian media and radio. I preach on evangelism, discernment, and bold Christian living in light of end-time Bible prophecy. I'm ordained and affiliated with Christian Ministerial Fellowship International-CMFI cmfi.org.uk. My wife Erika and I have four children and live in Carmel, Indiana.